Disciplining your child can be challenging, especially when emotions are high and patience is being tested. Many parents feel frustrated when yelling or punishment doesn’t lead to better behavior. This guide will help you understand why traditional methods like yelling may not work and how to approach discipline in a way that encourages positive changes.
Effective discipline techniques for teens without yelling
Good discipline works best when you stay calm and guide your child without fear or aggression. Yelling or hitting can harm relationships and create resistance, so calmer methods are a kinder, more effective way to help your child learn and grow.¹ These techniques help maintain authority while promoting respect and learning:
Calm down before responding
When emotions run high, it’s easy to react impulsively. Taking a moment to breathe allows you to address the situation constructively.2 To calm yourself and respond thoughtfully:
- Take deep breaths: Step away briefly and practice deep breathing to reduce tension before addressing your teen.
- Pause to gather your thoughts: Reflect on what happened and decide on an appropriate response.
- Acknowledge your emotions: Recognize your frustration without letting it control your reaction.
Remove privileges immediately
Loss of privileges can be helpful because it may encourage teens to recognize that their actions have immediate consequences. To ensure it has a meaningful impact:
- Identify a privilege that matters: Choose something meaningful, like screen time or outings.
- Be consistent and immediate: Apply the consequence as soon as the behavior occurs.
- Explain the reason clearly: Let them know why the privilege is being taken away.
Offer natural or logical consequences
Natural or logical consequences help teens understand how their choices lead to real-life outcomes, which can encourage better decision-making.2 These consequences are most effective when you:
- Relate consequences to the behavior: For example, if they miss curfew, limit their outings the following weekend to show how their actions affect privileges.
- Let natural consequences play out: If they forget to do homework, allow them to face the resulting grade so they learn from their own mistakes.
- Avoid overly harsh punishments: Stick to consequences that match the behavior, like reducing screen time for missing homework instead of banning it for an entire week.
Implement a behavior-specific ‘do-over’
A do-over can be effective because it offers teens an immediate chance to recognize their mistake, correct it, and practice the right behavior on the spot.
This approach may help reinforce positive behavior. To ensure do-overs lead to positive change:
- Address the issue immediately: If they spoke disrespectfully, have them repeat their words respectfully.
- Be specific about the correction: Clarify what needs to change, such as tone or language.
- Praise their effort: Acknowledge when they correct their behavior willingly.
Give a verbal warning with one follow-through
Warnings help teens adjust their behavior before facing consequences. To ensure warnings are taken seriously:
- Be clear about the warning: State the behavior you want to stop and the consequences that will follow.
- Limit to one warning: Avoid multiple warnings that weaken authority.
- Follow through immediately: If the behavior continues, enforce the stated consequence.
Note: Don’t spank or physically punish your child because it can break their trust and harm their emotional growth. Instead, stay calm and gently show them how to manage their emotions. We understand that this isn’t an easy process, but if you would like professional support in this area, we’re here to help. Speak with our counselors to get the support you need.
How to manage your emotions to avoid yelling during disciplinary moments
Managing your feelings is crucial in parenting, especially during disciplinary moments. When you keep your cool, you avoid yelling and show your child how to handle strong feelings.³ Here are ways to help you stay calm when disciplining your teen:
Recognize your triggers
Understanding what sets off your frustration helps you respond thoughtfully instead of reacting impulsively:
- Notice when stress or fatigue affects your mood: Reflect on whether lack of sleep, work-related stress, or daily pressures make you more irritable when speaking with your child.
- Observe patterns of behavior that challenge you: Pay attention to situations where your child may repeatedly test boundaries, such as refusing to clean up or delaying bedtime.
- Track your reactions: Keep a mental or written log of moments when you felt frustration build up. Reviewing this can help you identify specific triggers and prepare for them.
Take a step back and breathe
Pausing to breathe before responding allows you to reset and respond with a calmer mind.³ To do this:
- Use breathing exercises: Deep breaths signal your body to relax, helping you regain control.
- Count to 10 before responding: This brief pause creates space between your emotions and actions.
- Step into another room if needed: Physically removing yourself from the situation for a moment can prevent yelling.
Practice positive self-talk
What you say to yourself during a difficult moment can affect how you handle discipline. Positive self-talk helps you stay calm and composed. To achieve this:
- Remind yourself of your goals: Say things like, “I want to teach, not punish,” or, “Staying calm will help my child learn.”
- Acknowledge your progress: Encourage yourself with statements like, “I’m handling this better than before.”
- Avoid self-criticism: Replace negative thoughts like “I always fail at this” with constructive ones like “I can handle this without yelling.”
Reflect on past disciplinary moments
Looking back on how you handled previous situations helps you improve your response the next time. You can do this by:
- Identifying moments when you stayed calm and what worked: For example, you might remember that stepping away helped diffuse the situation.
- Reflecting on moments when you yelled: Consider why you lost control and what could have been done differently.
- Setting small improvement goals: Aim to reduce yelling step by step, such as handling one situation daily without raising your voice.
Find healthy outlets for stress
Managing your stress is important for keeping your emotions under control during discipline. When you stay calm, it’s easier to patiently handle problems with your child. Here are simple ways to help reduce stress and stay grounded:
- Exercise regularly: Physical activity helps release built-up tension and leaves you feeling more relaxed.
- Take short walks when feeling overwhelmed: A quick 10- to 15-minute walk can help reset your mood.
- Practice mindfulness or meditation: Daily mindfulness exercises help train your mind to stay present and reduce overreactions.
What if my child doesn’t respond to positive discipline techniques?
It can be frustrating when your child doesn’t respond to positive discipline techniques (discipline approaches that don’t involve yelling or hitting), but it doesn’t mean they can’t learn. Children take time to adjust to new boundaries, and some may need extra support. Here’s how you can troubleshoot and adjust your approach:
Stay consistent with your expectations
Consistency helps reinforce what behavior is acceptable and what is not. While you should be flexible when needed, the key is to keep rules and expectations steady so your child knows what to expect.¹ You can maintain consistency by:
- Enforcing the same rules daily: Make sure expectations are clear and don’t change based on mood or situation. For example, if bedtime is at 8 PM, enforce that every night.
- Following through on consequences: If you warn that screen time will be reduced for not finishing homework, stick to it without negotiating.
- Communicating with other caregivers: Ensure that everyone responsible for your child uses the same rules and consequences to avoid mixed signals.
Reflect on your current methods
Consistency is important, but it’s worth exploring new approaches if a particular technique hasn’t worked over time. Reflecting on your approach can help when you:
- Identify techniques that haven’t been effective: Notice which methods don’t help your kid improve their behavior. For example, if harsh punishments aren’t making a difference, try giving them a chance to make things right on their own.
- Think about your tone and timing: Correcting your child while still throwing tantrums often increases frustration and makes them less likely to listen. Wait until they are calm enough to listen, and use a gentle tone to explain the issue clearly.
- Observe patterns in misbehavior: Notice if there’s a specific trigger for certain behaviors, such as tiredness or hunger, and address the cause.
Adjust your discipline approach based on age and needs
Changing your approach ensures that you’re meeting their developmental and emotional needs:
- Younger children may need more redirection: Instead of long explanations, quickly guide them toward a positive activity. For example, if your young child gets upset because they can’t play with a toy right away, don’t spend too much time explaining why. Instead, suggest a fun alternative, like drawing a picture or reading a favorite book.
- Older children may benefit from problem-solving: Involve them in finding solutions by asking, “What can we do to avoid this problem next time?”
- Children with special needs may require tailored techniques: Depending on the child’s specific needs, some methods may work better than others. For example, children with ADHD might benefit from visual reminders or timers to help them stay on task. At the same time, those with sensory processing issues may respond well to calm verbal instructions paired with a behavior chart.
Reinforce positive behavior
If your teen isn’t responding to discipline, they may need more encouragement to see the benefits of positive actions. This works well when you:
- Offer immediate praise for small achievements: Acknowledge good behavior as soon as it happens, such as making a healthy decision, helping out at home, or showing responsibility in their studies.
- Celebrate progress, not perfection: Even small improvements deserve recognition. Saying, “I’m proud of you for trying,” builds their confidence.
- Set up a reward system that resonates: Consider a system where consistent positive behavior earns points toward privileges your teen values—like extra screen time, a later curfew, or a fun outing with friends.
Seek professional guidance if needed
If your child resists positive discipline despite your best efforts, talking to a professional can help. This can be useful when:
- You’re feeling overwhelmed: Parenting can be tough, so reaching out to a professional can offer new ideas to help you guide your child’s behavior.
- Signs of deeper issues show up: If your teen’s defiance seems more than just a phase, it might point to underlying emotional or developmental concerns.
- Strategies aren’t working: If you’ve tried several methods and nothing seems to change, a professional can help you find a better approach.
- Family relationships are strained: When your teen’s behavior starts affecting how your family interacts, getting outside help can restore balance and understanding.
Final thoughts
While positive discipline often works better than corporal punishment, every child is different. What works for one family might not work for another.
Stay flexible and patient, and adjust your approach to fit your child’s unique personality and age.
If you’re struggling with disciplining your child or feeling overwhelmed, our counselors at Avery’s House are ready to support you. Contact us today for personalized help.
(480) 360-4989
Speak To A Representative
Sources
1. American Academy of Pediatrics. Effective Discipline to Raise Healthy Children. Pediatrics. 2018;142(6):e20183112. doi:10.1542/peds.2018-3112
2. Nelsen J. Positive Discipline: The Classic Guide to Helping Children Develop Self-Discipline, Responsibility, Cooperation, and Problem-Solving Skills. 4th ed. New York, NY: Harmony; 2018.
3. Gershoff ET, Grogan-Kaylor A. Spanking and child outcomes: Old controversies and new meta-analyses. J Fam Psychol. 2016;30(4):453-469. doi:10.1037/fam0000191
Explore more helpful guides by categories
Mental health treatment for adolescents in Arizona
Is your teen struggling with their mental health? We’re here to help. Our specialized programs for teens, available across several Arizona locations, provide the care and support they need. Let’s work together to find the best path forward for your family.
Phoenix
Chandler
Author: Editorial Staff
FEBRUARY 6, 2025